chtnnh's Digital Garden

compressingQuantizedLanguageModels

10 min read

Compression Techniques for Quantized Language Models: A Comprehensive Guide

The increasing gap between the largest hardware and the largest language models necessitates innovative solutions to reduce model size and computational demands 1. This article aims to provide a comprehensive guide to understanding and implementing compression techniques for quantized large language models (LLMs), with a specific focus on the Qwen 2.5 model with 1.5 billion parameters, quantized to 4-bit integer precision and stored in the GGUF format 2. This guide will cover the fundamentals of the GGUF format, quantization, and various compression techniques, including practical examples and resources.

Understanding the GGUF Format

The GGUF (Generic GPT Unified Format) format is designed for storing and deploying quantized LLMs. It builds upon the GGML format, prioritizing compatibility, efficiency, and scalability. GGUF supports various quantization schemes, including common ones like 4-bit and 8-bit, allowing users to balance model size and precision 2. It is also compatible with existing tools like Python and Transformers libraries, making it a versatile format for deploying LLMs on different hardware and software platforms.

Quantization and its Role in LLM Compression

Quantization is a core technique for compressing LLMs. It involves reducing the precision of numerical values, typically from a higher-precision format (like 32-bit floating point - FP32) to a lower-precision format (like 8-bit integer - INT8 or 4-bit integer - INT4) 4. In the context of LLMs, this means converting the model’s weights and activation values to these lower-precision data types. This conversion process is inherently non-linear and irreversible, meaning some information might be lost during quantization 5.
This reduction in precision allows for significant reductions in model size and memory footprint, leading to faster inference speeds and lower computational costs 6. Quantization enables LLMs to use less memory and computing power, resulting in faster responses and reduced costs. However, it’s crucial to remember that this can also make AI inference less precise 7. There’s a trade-off between efficiency and accuracy, as the reduced precision can lead to quantization errors 6.
In signal processing applications, quantization errors contribute to noise and degrade the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). The SNR, measured in decibels (dB), generally shows a reduction for each bit of precision removed 8. This highlights the importance of carefully choosing the quantization level to balance compression and accuracy.

Types of Quantization

There are different approaches to applying quantization to LLMs 6:

  • Post-training quantization (PTQ): This involves applying quantization to an existing model after it has been trained. PTQ is faster and doesn’t require retraining, but it can lead to some performance degradation.
  • Quantization-aware training (QAT): This incorporates quantization during the training process, allowing the model to adapt to the lower precision and generally achieve better performance than PTQ. However, QAT requires more computational resources and data.
  • Dynamic quantization: This dynamically adjusts the quantization parameters during runtime, making it suitable for models with varying input distributions.

The choice between these approaches depends on factors like the desired accuracy, available resources, and the specific LLM being compressed.

Common Compression Techniques for Quantized LLMs

Model compression techniques are effective because neural networks, especially large ones, are often over-parameterized, meaning they have more parameters than necessary to achieve good performance 9. This redundancy allows for compression without significant accuracy loss. Here are some common techniques used to compress quantized LLMs:
Quantization-based Techniques

  • Post-Training Quantization (PTQ): As mentioned earlier, PTQ involves applying quantization to an already trained model 9. This method is relatively fast and does not require retraining the model. However, it can lead to some performance degradation due to the direct conversion of an existing model to a smaller size 6.
  • Quantization-Aware Training (QAT): QAT incorporates quantization during the training process 10. This allows the model to adapt to the lower precision, leading to better performance compared to PTQ. However, QAT requires significant computational resources and a large amount of training data 6.

Other Compression Techniques

  • Pruning: Pruning involves removing unnecessary components from the model, such as weights, neurons, or even entire layers 11. This can reduce the model size and complexity without significant performance loss. Pruning can be done in various ways, including unstructured pruning (removing individual weights) and structured pruning (removing entire structures) 9.
  • Knowledge Distillation: Knowledge distillation involves training a smaller “student” model to mimic the behavior of a larger “teacher” model 9. This can effectively transfer knowledge from a complex model to a smaller, more efficient one.
  • Low-Rank Factorization: Low-rank factorization techniques aim to approximate weight matrices with lower-rank matrices, reducing the number of parameters and computations 12.
  • Additive Quantization (AQ): AQ is a more advanced technique that compresses multiple values jointly by leveraging the mutual information of quantized values 13. This can lead to better compression ratios compared to direct quantization methods.

It’s important to note that these techniques can be combined for maximum compression. For example, one could use knowledge distillation to create a smaller model and then apply quantization and pruning to further reduce its size and complexity.

Measuring the Effectiveness of Compression Techniques

Evaluating the effectiveness of different compression techniques is crucial to ensure the desired balance between model size and performance. When choosing a compression algorithm, it’s essential to consider factors like speed, compression ratio, complexity, space requirements, latency, and interoperability 14. Here are some key metrics to consider:

  • Compression Ratio: This measures the reduction in model size achieved by the compression technique. It is calculated as the ratio of the original model size to the compressed model size.
  • Inference Speed: This measures how fast the compressed model can generate responses. It is typically measured in tokens per second.
  • Accuracy: This measures the performance of the compressed model on specific tasks, such as text generation or question answering. It can be evaluated using metrics like perplexity, BLEU score, or accuracy on benchmark datasets.
  • Memory Footprint: This measures the amount of memory required to load and run the compressed model.
  • Computational Cost: This measures the computational resources required for inference, which can be evaluated in terms of FLOPs (floating-point operations) or energy consumption.

It’s important to select the most relevant metrics based on the specific application and deployment environment. For example, if deploying on resource-constrained devices, memory footprint and inference speed might be more critical than a slight drop in accuracy.
When evaluating video compression quality, it’s important to consider both subjective (human perception) and objective (data-driven) metrics 15. Different codecs produce different visual impairments, so a holistic approach to evaluation is necessary.

Implementing Compression for a Quantized LLM in GGUF Format

Here are some resources and examples for implementing compression for a quantized LLM in the GGUF format:

  • llama.cpp: This is a popular library for quantizing and running LLMs. It provides tools for converting models to the GGUF format and supports various quantization levels 2. You can use the convert.py script in the llama.cpp repository to convert models to GGUF, and the quantize example to further quantize the model to smaller formats like Q4_K_M 16.
  • Hugging Face Transformers: This library provides integration with compressed-tensors, a versatile library for storing and managing compressed model checkpoints in various formats, including GGUF 17. You can use the llm-compressor tool to create compressed models and then load them using the HFQuantizer integration in Transformers.
  • LLM Compressor: This framework allows applying state-of-the-art quantization and compression techniques to LLMs, including GPTQ, AWQ, and SmoothQuant 18. It supports multimodal models and provides examples for quantizing models like Whisper and Llama 2 Vision. You can install it using pip install llmcompressor>=0.4.0 and then use the GPTQModifier to apply GPTQ quantization with various configurations.

Specific Advice for Compressing Qwen 2.5 with 4-bit Integer Precision

  • Consider using GPTQ: GPTQ (Generative Pre-trained Transformer Quantization) is a popular post-training quantization technique that has shown promising results for LLMs, including Qwen 2.5 18. LLM Compressor provides tools and examples for applying GPTQ to various models.
  • Experiment with different quantization schemes: The GGUF format supports various quantization schemes. Experiment with different options (e.g., Q4_K_M) to find the best balance between model size and performance 16. You can use llama.cpp to quantize to different GGUF formats.
  • Use appropriate tools: Utilize tools like llama.cpp or llm-compressor to quantize and compress the model effectively 2.
  • Monitor performance: Carefully evaluate the impact of compression on the model’s performance using metrics like perplexity or accuracy on downstream tasks 20. If performance degradation is unacceptable, consider using a less aggressive quantization scheme or a different compression technique.
  • Consider higher bit precision for optimal accuracy: While 4-bit quantization is possible, for optimal accuracy with Qwen 2.5, using a larger model with less aggressive quantization (e.g., 16-bit) might be preferable 20. This allows for a better balance between model size and performance.
Quantization SchemeBit PrecisionCompression RatioPerformance ImpactMemory Footprint
FP3232-bit1xBaselineHighest
FP1616-bit2xMinimal degradationLower
INT88-bit4xModerate degradationLower
INT44-bit8xPotentially significant degradationLowest

Conclusion

Compressing quantized LLMs like Qwen 2.5 with 4-bit integer precision is crucial for deploying these powerful models efficiently. By understanding the GGUF format, quantization techniques, and various compression methods, you can effectively reduce the model size and computational cost while maintaining acceptable performance.
Key Takeaways

  • Quantization: Reduces model size and computational cost by lowering the precision of numerical values, but can introduce accuracy trade-offs.
  • Compression Techniques: Various techniques like PTQ, QAT, pruning, knowledge distillation, and low-rank factorization can be used to compress LLMs.
  • GGUF Format: A versatile format for storing and deploying quantized LLMs, supporting various quantization schemes and tools.
  • Evaluation: It’s crucial to measure the effectiveness of compression techniques using appropriate metrics and consider both subjective and objective evaluations.

When compressing Qwen 2.5 with 4-bit precision, carefully consider the trade-off between model size and accuracy. While aggressive quantization can significantly reduce size, it might lead to noticeable performance degradation. Experiment with different quantization schemes and compression techniques to find the optimal balance for your specific needs. Tools like llama.cpp and LLM Compressor can help you achieve this.
The field of LLM compression is constantly evolving, with new techniques and tools emerging. Staying informed about the latest advancements is essential for effectively deploying these powerful models in various applications.

Works cited

1. How to make Large Language Models smaller and faster?(Quantization) | by Kerem Aydın, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://medium.com/@aydinKerem/how-to-make-large-language-models-smaller-and-faster-quantization-a42765bdf2d7
2. How to Convert Models to GGUF Format? - Analytics Vidhya, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://www.analyticsvidhya.com/blog/2024/10/convert-models-to-gguf-format/
3. Understanding the GGUF Format: A Comprehensive Guide | by …, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://medium.com/@vimalkansal/understanding-the-gguf-format-a-comprehensive-guide-67de48848256
4. www.ibm.com, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://www.ibm.com/think/topics/quantization#:~:text=Quantization%20is%20the%20process%20of,data%20compression%20and%20machine%20learning.
5. Quantization (signal processing) - Wikipedia, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantization_(signal_processing)
6. What is Quantization? | IBM, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://www.ibm.com/think/topics/quantization
7. What is quantization in machine learning? - Cloudflare, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://www.cloudflare.com/learning/ai/what-is-quantization/
8. What Is Quantization? | How It Works & Applications - MATLAB & Simulink - MathWorks, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://www.mathworks.com/discovery/quantization.html
9. Compressing Large Language Models (LLMs) - Towards Data Science, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://towardsdatascience.com/compressing-large-language-models-llms-9f406eea5b5e/
10. A Comprehensive Study on Quantization Techniques for Large Language Models - arXiv, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.02530
11. Compression techniques for Large Language Models | by Dr. Nimrita Koul - Medium, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://medium.com/@nimritakoul01/compression-techniques-for-large-language-models-8efe3c4a8b92
12. 4 Popular Model Compression Techniques Explained - Xailient, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://xailient.com/blog/4-popular-model-compression-techniques-explained/
13. Extreme Compression of Large Language Models via Additive Quantization - arXiv, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06118
14. Data Compression/Evaluating Compression Effectiveness - Wikibooks, open books for an open world, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Data_Compression/Evaluating_Compression_Effectiveness
15. How to Measure Video Compression Quality: A Quick-Start Guide - intoPIX, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://www.intopix.com/blogs/post/How-to-Measure-Video-Compression-Quality
16. Quantizing LLM to GGML or GUFF Format: A Comprehensive Guide #4068 - GitHub, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://github.com/ggml-org/llama.cpp/discussions/4068
17. Compressed Tensors - Hugging Face, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://huggingface.co/docs/transformers/quantization/compressed_tensors
18. Multimodal Model Quantization Support Through LLM Compressor - Neural Magic, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://neuralmagic.com/blog/multimodal-model-quantization-support-through-llm-compressor/
19. Qwen/Qwen2.5-32B-Instruct-GPTQ-Int4 - Hugging Face, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://huggingface.co/Qwen/Qwen2.5-32B-Instruct-GPTQ-Int4
20. Qwen2.5 - more parameters or less quantization? : r/LocalLLaMA - Reddit, accessed on March 7, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/LocalLLaMA/comments/1gnomrv/qwen25_more_parameters_or_less_quantization/

Graph View